Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc logo

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc

Private foundation · Grantmaker Madison, IN EIN: 86-2593306 Website

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc is a private foundation based in Madison, Indiana. It makes grants to nonprofits, schools, churches, and government entities for activities serving Jefferson County residents, with a stated aim of building a healthier Jefferson County through collaboration and sustainable change.

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc at a glance

In short: Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc gave $5.0M across 32 grants in 2024 (avg $157K), mostly in Indiana. Source: 2024 IRS Form 990-PF.

Annual giving (2024)
$5,037,696
+9.9% vs 2023
Grants made (2024)
32
-20.0% vs 2023
Average grant
$157,428
+37.3% vs 2023
Median grant
$67,500
Total assets
$158,346,277
+4.4% vs 2023
Primary geography
Indiana (89% of itemized 2024 grant dollars)
Latest 990 filing
Form 990-PF, 2024 View filing

Data from IRS Form 990-PF, 2024; updated October 2026.

How to apply to Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc

How to Apply

Applicants use the foundation’s grant application portal. Projects must align with the foundation’s pillars and focus areas. The foundation’s filing says the application requests a description of grant use and gives priority to requests that include a hopeful, strengths-based culture, potential for systems impact, collaboration, multigenerational and peer-supported approaches, and innovation. The filing states that prospective grantees need to inquire with the foundation about deadlines.

Contact

Application contact: Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc
Mailing address: 310 West Street, Madison, IN 47250
Phone: (812) 916-4390
Email: info@bethanylegacy.org
Website: https://bethanylegacy.org

Application details from Grantable's research on the foundation's public materials; confirm on its website before applying.

Who Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc funds

How this funder distributes its grants

Top Recipients

Top 10 recipients in 2024

City of Madison: $892K across 2 grantsCity of Madison$892K · 2 grantsSouthwestern Jefferson County Consolidated School Corporation: $650KSouthwestern Jefferson CountyConsolidated School…$650KHome Ownership Center of Greater Cincinnati: $550KHome Ownership Center ofGreater Cincinnati$550KChoices Coordinated Care Solutions Inc: $382KChoices Coordinated CareSolutions Inc$382KLide White Memorial Boys & Girls Club DBA Boys & Girls Club of Jefferson C: $380K across 2 grantsLide White Memorial Boys &Girls Club DBA Boys & Girls…$380K · 2 grantsNorton King's Daughters Health: $300KNorton King's Daughters Health$300KThe Salvation Army: $275KThe Salvation Army$275KJefferson County Government: $250KJefferson County Government$250KGirls Inc of Jefferson County IN: $202K across 2 grantsGirls Inc of Jefferson CountyIN$202K · 2 grantsMadison Consolidated School Corporation: $199KMadison Consolidated SchoolCorporation$199K

The largest 2024 recipient was City of Madison ($892K across 2 grants). Together the top 10 received $4.1M.

Grant Size Distribution

75 grants across all recorded years

35<$50K8$50–100K18$100–250K9$250–500K5$500K–1M$1–5M$5M+

The most common grant size was under $50K: 35 grants of 75 (47%).

Geographic Focus

Where this funder awards grants

The foundation says its work is intended to build a healthier Jefferson County, Indiana, and its filing states that grant-funded activities must serve Jefferson County residents. In 2024, 89% of grant dollars went to recipients in Indiana and 11% to recipients in Ohio.

Grant Distribution by State

2states

Share of 2024 grant dollars across all 32 itemized grants.

States

Cities

MadisonHanoverCincinnatiDupontIndianapolisCanaanDillsboroLexington

How Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc gives

  • 21% of 2024 grantees were also funded in 2023. Method
  • In 2024 it paid out 105% of its IRS minimum distribution (the 5% rule). Method

Estimate from itemized grant lists in IRS Form 990-PF filings (2024). Recipient names are matched across years, so a renamed or misspelled grantee can look new; grants to individuals are left out. Methodology.

Giving History

Giving Over Time

Total grant dollars and number of grants per year

$0$2M$4M$6M0 grants2021 3 grants2022 40 grants2023 32 grants2024

From 2022 to 2024, annual grant giving ranged from $69K (2022) to $5.0M (2024). In 2024 it made 32 grants totaling $5.0M.

Grants by year

Grant recipients and amounts by year

RecipientPurposeAmount
City of Madison Madison, INStrong Youth, Empowered Adults, Stable Seniors$875,000
Southwestern Jefferson County Consolidated School Corporation Hanover, INStrong Youth, Empowered Adults, Stable Seniors$650,000
Home Ownership Center of Greater Cincinnati Cincinnati, OHStrategic Investment$550,000
Choices Coordinated Care Solutions Inc Indianapolis, INStrong Youth$382,000
Lide White Memorial Boys & Girls Club DBA Boys & Girls Club of Jefferson C Madison, INStrong Youth, Empowered Adults$355,411
Norton King's Daughters Health Madison, INStrategic Investment$300,000
The Salvation Army Madison, INEmpowered Adults, Stable Seniors$275,000
Jefferson County Government Madison, INEmpowered Adults$250,000
Madison Consolidated School Corporation Madison, INStrong Youth, Empowered Adults$199,000
Habitat for Humanity of Southeast Indiana Madison, INStrong Youth, Empowered Adults$197,585
Your AI grants department

Ready to take the next step with Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc?

Fully replaces Grant database subscriptions Instrumentl · Foundation Directory · GrantStation & similar

Financial History

Multi-year comparison from IRS filings

Figures from IRS filings, by filing year
Filing yearTotal AssetsRevenueExpensesGrants paidGrantsQualifying DistributionsNet Investment IncomeDistributable Amount
2024$158,346,277$8,220,018$6,850,361$5,037,69632$6,162,987$7,724,003$5,874,338
2023$151,671,767$4,809,712$6,295,882$4,585,52840$5,569,884$4,143,838$5,395,372
2022$140,812,186$141,754,702$755,497$68,5033$743,048$2,092,611$3,889,584
2021$88,741$81,787$47—————

Under IRS private-foundation payout rules, Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc reported a distributable amount of $5.9M for 2024 — the minimum it must pay out in qualifying distributions.

Research compiled by Grantable AI from public sources. Last updated October 2026.

Mission & Focus Areas

The foundation’s stated mission is to bring people together to create sustainable change where it is needed most. Its Legacy 2030 strategy focuses on childcare, mental health, housing, transportation, recreation, social services, and professional development. Its grant pillars include strong youth, empowered adults, stable seniors, and a robust workforce.

The foundation supports nonprofits, schools, churches, and government entities. Examples among its 2024 grantees include CHOICES Coordinated Care Solutions, whose stated mission is to strengthen youth and families while enhancing systems and communities; Habitat for Humanity of Southeast Indiana, which says it works to create decent, affordable housing; and River Valley Resources, which says it develops a competitive workforce through collaboration and innovative services.

Grantmaking

In 2024, the foundation reported 32 grants totaling $5,037,696. Individual grants ranged from $50 to $875,000, with a median of $67,500. Notable awards included $875,000 to the City of Madison, $650,000 to Southwestern Jefferson County Consolidated School Corporation, $550,000 to Home Ownership Center of Greater Cincinnati, and $382,000 to CHOICES Coordinated Care Solutions.

The foundation’s website lists long applications for requests above $50,000, short applications for requests of $50,000 or less, and capacity-building applications for requests of $20,000 or less per calendar year. The long application requires an accepted pre-application; the short and capacity-building applications use a single application form. The stated review periods are approximately 12 weeks for the long application and six weeks for the other two. The website says the 2026 funding opportunities are closed. It says application questions and due dates are posted in the first quarter of each year.

The foundation says it will not fund health care levies, lobbying or political campaigns, scholarships, or endowments. It also will not fund projects where its grant would account for more than 40% of the lead organization’s total operating budget, or organizations, programs, or projects that discriminate based on religious participation or membership, race, gender, citizenship status, sexual orientation, age, or disability. Grant funds are not intended to replace existing funding sources.

Leadership & Key People

Leadership team and compensation from IRS filings

The 2024 filing lists Dora Anim as CEO/President; Julie Berry as Chair; Sharyn Whitman as Vice Chair; Leslie Grote as Treasurer; Jackie Thurston as Secretary; and Darlene Connolly, Susan Craig, Valecia Crisafulli, Susan Ohlendorf, and Annie Schroeder as directors.

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc is led by Dora Anim, CEO & President on every filing since 2022; 1 of 10 officers listed in 2024 is compensated.

Officers on the 2024 filing

  • Dora Anim

    CEO & President

    On filings since 2022

    40 hrs/week

    $179K (2022) → $360K (2024)

  • Julie Berry

    Chair

    Vice Chair → Chair, 2024

    On filings since 2022

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Annie Schroeder

    Director

    Chair → Director, 2024

    On filings since 2021

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Valecia Crisafulli

    Director

    Board Member → Director, 2022

    On filings since 2021

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Darlene Connolly

    Director

    New on the 2024 filing

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Susan Craig

    Director

    New on the 2024 filing

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Susan Ohlendorf

    Director

    New on the 2024 filing

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Sharyn Whitman

    Vice Chair

    Treasurer → Vice Chair, 2024

    On filings since 2021

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Jackie Thurston

    Secretary

    Director → Secretary, 2024

    On filings since 2022

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Leslie Grote

    Treasurer

    New on the 2024 filing

    5 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

Former officers (4)
  • Former: Darleen Connolly (2021–2023) — Chair
  • Former: Molly Dodge (2021–2022) — Secretary
  • Former: Kathy Rohlfing (2022) — Director
  • Former: Bonnie Colen (2021) — Secretary

Data from IRS Form 990 filings, 2021–2024. "On filings since" is the earliest filing we hold that lists the person; hours are average hours per week as reported.

Compensation Overview

From 2024 IRS filing

Dora Anim — CEO/President: $360KDora AnimCEO/President$360K

The highest reported compensation on the 2024 filing was $360K, to Dora Anim (CEO/President).

Frequently asked questions about Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc

How much does Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc give each year?

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc gave $5.0M across 32 grants in 2024, according to its 2024 IRS Form 990-PF. In 2023 it gave $4.6M across 40 grants.

What is Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's typical grant size?

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's median grant in 2024 was $67,500, and its average grant was $157,428, across 32 grants on its 2024 IRS Form 990-PF.

Where does Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc give grants?

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc gives mostly in Indiana: 89% of the grant dollars itemized on its 2024 IRS Form 990-PF went to recipients there. The next largest state was Ohio (11%). The most frequent recipient cities were Madison, IN (24 grants), Hanover, IN (3 grants) and Indianapolis, IN (2 grants).

Does Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc give general operating support?

Yes: 25% of Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's 2024 grants with a stated purpose (8 of 32) were for general or operating support, per its 2024 IRS Form 990-PF. Recurring purposes include "Strong Youth" (5 grants), "Strong Youth, Empowered Adults" (5 grants) and "Strategic Investment" (4 grants).

Who are Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's largest grantees?

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's largest 2024 grantees include City of Madison ($892,209 across 2 grants), Southwestern Jefferson County Consolidated School Corporation ($650,000) and Home Ownership Center of Greater Cincinnati ($550,000), according to its 2024 IRS Form 990-PF. Together they received 42% of its itemized 2024 grant dollars.

How large is Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc?

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc reported $158.3M in total assets on its 2024 IRS Form 990-PF. It paid out $6.2M in qualifying distributions that year, against a required minimum of $5.9M (roughly 5% of its investment assets).

What does Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc fund?

The foundation’s stated mission is to bring people together to create sustainable change where it is needed most. Its Legacy 2030 strategy focuses on childcare, mental health, housing, transportation, recreation, social services, and professional development. See mission & focus areas ↑

How do I apply for a grant from Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc?

Applicants use the foundation’s grant application portal. Eligibility and process details are in the grantmaking section of this profile. See how to apply ↑

What is Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's EIN?

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's EIN (Employer Identification Number) is 86-2593306. IRS Form 990 filing data is available on this page for 2021–2024.

Data last updated October 2026. Sourced from IRS Form 990-PF filings. Research dossier generated October 2026.

Data update history

(1)

When this profile's IRS filing data changed on Grantable

  1. IRS filings on file for fiscal years 2021–2024

Live grants for the work Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc funds

Health Open opportunities, soonest deadline first.

Explore Open Grants

Browse active grant opportunities in Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's focus areas in our free grants database

Similar Funders

Funders that support many of the same organizations

Community Foundation of Madison and Jefferson County Inc

Madison, IN

The Community Foundation of Madison and Jefferson County funds nonprofits serving Jefferson County, Indiana, across areas such as education, youth development, health, basic needs, and historic preservation; it prioritizes projects, collaboration, capacity-building, and pilot services over routine operating costs. Its 2025 grants ranged from $5,100 to $70,880, with a median of $13,100; it offers competitive grants through an application process, but the profile does not state whether it accepts unsolicited requests.

Philanthropy, Voluntarism & Grantmaking

Assets

$52.5M

Grants

45

Total Given

$999K

Lilly Endowment Inc

Indianapolis, IN

Lilly Endowment funds community development, education and youth, and religion, with priority given to Indianapolis and Indiana and some national support, especially for religion. Its 2025 grants had a median of $100,000, though awards varied widely; for community development requests, it suggests starting with a brief preliminary letter.

Assets

$105.9B

Grants

2,285

Total Given

$3.9B

Jefferson County United Way Inc

Madison, IN

Soliciting contributions to allocate among various united way agencies.

Philanthropy, Voluntarism & Grantmaking

Assets

$478K

Grants

6

Total Given

$108K

Arvin Sango Foundation

Madison, IN

The Arvin Sango Foundation supports education and training, youth organizations, United Way agencies, health and disease research, public safety, community services, and arts and sciences, primarily in Indiana. Recent grants ranged from $100 to $29,300, with a median of $2,000. It accepts written requests at any time.

Philanthropy, Voluntarism & Grantmaking

Assets

$3.3M

Grants

43

Total Given

$184K

Arkwright Foundation

Spartanburg, SC

The Arkwright Foundation supports charitable organizations working in education, health and dental services, community assistance, arts and culture, and food access, primarily in South Carolina. Its 2024 grants ranged from $50 to $273,700, with a median of $2,000; charitable organizations may contact the foundation by letter, personal visit, or phone call, and no deadline is listed.

Assets

$16.8M

Grants

101

Total Given

$970K

The Scripps Howard Foundation

Cincinnati, OH

The foundation supports journalism education and related programs that foster informed, engaged communities, including journalism fellowships and environmental and technology-focused journalism initiatives. In 2024, grants ranged from $25 to $675,706, with a median of $1,250; funding was concentrated in Maryland and Washington, D.C., followed by Arizona, Ohio, and Colorado. The profile does not state whether it accepts unsolicited requests.

Philanthropy, Voluntarism & Grantmaking

Assets

$69.4M

Grants

819

Total Given

$7.4M

More similar funders

More Funders in Indiana

Cite this profile

Grantable. (2026). Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc funder profile. GrantGraph. Retrieved October 19, 2026, from https://grantable.co/funders/bethany-legacy-foundation-inc-morg_93cab95bc2dd483f822cda6ae5938baf

BibTeX
@misc{grantable_862593306_2026,
  author       = {{Grantable}},
  title        = {{Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc funder profile}},
  howpublished = {GrantGraph},
  year         = {2026},
  url          = {https://grantable.co/funders/bethany-legacy-foundation-inc-morg_93cab95bc2dd483f822cda6ae5938baf},
  note         = {Accessed 2026-10-19. Data licensed CC BY 4.0}
}

The figures on this page are open data under CC BY 4.0: reuse them with credit to Grantable and a link. Download the data.

Figures come from Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc's IRS filings (methodology). AI-written summaries, news items and logos are not covered by the open licence. Spot an error? Email hello@grantable.co.

Bethany Legacy Foundation Inc down — hundreds of funders to go?

Want AI to do this for you?