Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc logo

Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc

Public charity · Grantmaker Sag Harbor, NY EIN: 13-3628854 Website

Bay street theatre is a regional theater presenting new, classic and contemporary works, with a commitment to challenging and entertaining our diverse community. This commitment extends to innovative educational programs that highlight the power of live theater. It is our mission to be an artistic haven for an extended family of artists and audience, while continuing to provide a gathering place to share in the unique collective theatrical experience.

Key facts about Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc

EIN
13-3628854
Latest 990 filing
Form 990, 2025
Total assets
$1,676,111

Data from IRS Form 990, 2025; updated September 2026.

Financial Overview

From 2025 IRS Form 990 · View filing

Total Assets

$1.7M

-23.2% YoY

Revenue

$5.7M

+4.8% YoY

Net Investment Income

$32K

-48.8% YoY

Expenses

$5.8M

+5.9% YoY

About Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc

Based on IRS filings

Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc is a public charity focused on Arts, Culture & Humanities, based in Sag Harbor, NY. IRS filing data is available from 2019 through 2025. As of 2025, the organization holds $1.7M in total assets. Net investment income was $32K.

Your AI grants department

Ready to take the next step with Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc?

Fully replaces Grant database subscriptions Instrumentl · Foundation Directory · GrantStation & similar

Geographic Focus

Where this funder awards grants

States

Cities

Philadelphia

Giving Over Time

Total grant dollars and number of grants per year

$0$2K$4K$6K0 grants2019 1 grant2020 0 grants2021 0 grants2022 0 grants2023 0 grants2024 0 grants2025

In 2020 it made 1 grant totaling $6K.

Financial History

Multi-year comparison from IRS filings

Revenue
Expenses
Net Investment Income
$0$2M$4M$6M$8M2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Metric202520242023
Total Assets$1,676,111$2,182,639$2,549,136
Revenue$5,650,425$5,393,918$4,625,633
Expenses$5,837,528$5,511,986$5,190,891
Net Investment Income$31,712$61,892$39,918

Data update history

When this profile's IRS filing data changed on Grantable

  1. Added Form 990 for fiscal year 2019 (received by the IRS August 3, 2020)
  2. Updated Form 990 for fiscal year 2020 (received by the IRS November 15, 2021)
  3. Added Form 990 for fiscal year 2025 (received by the IRS July 2, 2026)

Leadership & Key People

Officers and directors from IRS filings

Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc is led by Tracy Mitchell, President & Executive Director since 2020 (on filings since 2019); 2 of 24 officers listed in 2025 are compensated.

Officers on the 2025 filing

  • Tracy Mitchell

    President & Executive Director

    Executive Director → President & Executive Director, 2020

    On filings since 2019

    40 hrs/week

    $145K (2019) → $215K (2025)

  • Steven Todrys

    Chairman

    On filings since 2019

    2 hrs/week

    No compensation reported

  • Lynn Mestel

    Co-Chairman

    Trustee → Co-Chairman, 2025

    On filings since 2024

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Carol Konner

    Trustee

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Christine Wachter-Campbell

    Trustee

    Secretary → Vicechair, 2024

    Vicechair → Trustee, 2025

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • David Fink

    Trustee

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Eric Segal

    Trustee

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Flora Schnall

    Trustee

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Joy Behar

    Trustee

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Richard Kind

    Trustee

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Riki Kane Larimer

    Trustee

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Dan Gasby

    Trustee

    On filings since 2020

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Stewart F. Lane

    Trustee

    On filings since 2021

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Myra Hackel

    Trustee

    On filings since 2023

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Nina Lesavoy

    Trustee

    On filings since 2023

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Elise Leve

    Trustee

    On filings since 2024

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Jennifer Bartley

    Trustee

    On filings since 2024

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Keith Green

    Trustee

    On filings since 2024

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Leslie Mayer

    Trustee

    On filings since 2024

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Loretta Kaufman

    Trustee

    On filings since 2024

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Laura McPhail

    Trustee

    New on the 2025 filing

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • Chris Siefert

    Deputy Director

    On filings since 2024

    40 hrs/week

    $152K (2024) → $151K (2025)

  • Wendy Harrison Hashmall

    Secretary

    Secretary → Trustee, 2023

    Trustee → Secretary, 2024

    On filings since 2019

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

  • John Frawley

    Treasurer

    Trustee → Treasurer, 2022

    On filings since 2021

    1 hr/week

    No compensation reported

Former officers (13)
  • Former: Mala Sander (2019–2024) — Trustee
  • Former: Patty Baker (2019–2024) — Trustee
  • Former: Scott Schwartz (2019–2024) — Director
  • Former: Luigi Caiola (2019–2023) — Trustee
  • Former: Christopher Siefert (2022–2023) — Assistant Executive Director
  • Former: Ian Ziskin (2019–2021) — Treasurer
  • Former: Andrea Wahlquist (2019–2020) — Trustee
  • Former: Erik Batt (2019–2020) — Trustee
  • Former: Karin Kuhns (2019–2020) — Trustee
  • Former: Martin Gould (2019–2020) — Trustee
  • Former: Steve Sanders (2019–2020) — Trustee
  • Former: Adrianne Cohen (2019) — Trustee
  • Former: Andrew Newman (2019) — Treasurer

Data from IRS Form 990 filings, 2019–2025. "On filings since" is the earliest filing we hold that lists the person; hours are average hours per week as reported.

Compensation Overview

From 2025 IRS filing

Tracy Mitchell — Pres/Exec DIR: $215KTracy MitchellPres/Exec DIR$215KChris Siefert — Deputy Director: $151KChris SiefertDeputy Director$151K

The highest reported compensation on the 2025 filing was $215K, to Tracy Mitchell (Pres/Exec DIR). 2 officers or directors reported compensation on that filing.

Frequently asked questions about Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc

How large is Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc?

Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc reported $1.7M in total assets on its 2025 IRS Form 990. Its revenue that year was $5.7M.

What is Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc?

Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc is a public charity focused on Arts, Culture & Humanities, based in Sag Harbor, NY. It holds $1.7M in total assets as of 2025.

Where does Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc operate?

Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc has awarded grants in Pennsylvania.

What is Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc's EIN?

Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc's EIN (Employer Identification Number) is 13-3628854. IRS Form 990 filing data is available on this page for 2019–2025.

Data last updated September 2026. Sourced from IRS Form 990 filings.

Your AI grants department

Here's the math on researching Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc by hand.

Explore Open Grants

Browse active grant opportunities in Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc's focus areas in our free grants database

Similar Funders

Other grantmakers to research

Higher Ground Foundation Inc

Elkins Park, PA

Higher Ground Foundation, inc. Was founded in 2019 for the purpose of building and operating a museum. It is currently in the fund-raising stage of launching this museum.

Assets

$674K

Grants

1

Total Given

$25K

Lipper Family Charitable Foundation

Summit, NJ

Assets

$856K

Grants

2

Total Given

$25K

Stronger Fairer Forward

Maplewood, NJ

Assets

—

Grants

2

Total Given

$91K

Armin and Ethel Schaper Charitable Foundation

Purchase, NY

Assets

—

Grants

3

Total Given

$6K

Cole Family Foundation

New York, NY

The Cole Family Foundation supports a varied range of charitable work, including early childhood, conservation, Alzheimer’s research, literature, student leadership, and legal services, with most recent funding going to New York organizations and some to Massachusetts and California. Its 2025 grants ranged from $500 to $15,000, with a median of $2,000. It funds only preselected organizations and does not accept unsolicited requests.

Assets

$2.7M

Grants

14

Total Given

$55K

Farms for Life Foundation

Batavia, IL

The foundation’s 2025 grants supported organizations focused on pregnancy support, opposition to abortion, child hunger, and education. It awarded 20 grants totaling $848,000, ranging from $2,000 to $500,000, with a median of $14,375; most funding went to organizations in Indiana and Illinois. It gives only to preselected organizations and does not accept unsolicited requests.

Assets

$19.4M

Grants

20

Total Given

$848K

Halsey Family Foundation Inc

Southampton, NY

Public, Societal Benefit

Assets

$472K

Grants

20

Total Given

$26K

Laurence Family Foundation Inc

Hialeah, FL

The Laurence Family Foundation supports a range of charitable organizations, including those focused on health, homelessness, food access, and animal welfare. Its 2024 grants ranged from $1,250 to $6,000, with a median of $3,000, and went to organizations in several states, especially Florida, New York, and Washington, DC. It gives only to preselected organizations and does not accept unsolicited requests.

Philanthropy, Voluntarism & Grantmaking

Assets

$875K

Grants

22

Total Given

$61K

The Walter Reade Foundation Inc

New York, NY

The Walter Reade Foundation funds a varied mix of education, food access, public safety, religious institutions, and arts organizations, with recent grants concentrated in California and New York. Its 2025 grants ranged from $100 to $5,700, with a median of $1,000; the filing says no application materials or deadlines are required and there are no award restrictions.

Assets

$800K

Grants

36

Total Given

$61K

The Honickman Foundation

Philadelphia, PA

The Honickman Foundation supports arts, health, education, social change, and heritage, with most of its giving going to organizations in Pennsylvania, especially Philadelphia. Its 2024 grants ranged from $500 to $180,000, with a median of $2,500; it does not accept unsolicited requests and gives only to preselected organizations.

Assets

$13.7M

Grants

68

Total Given

$832K

The Foodbank of Monmouth and Ocean Counties Inc D/B/a Fulfill

Neptune, NJ

Fulfill funds food security and related pantry assistance, including emergency food programs, food purchases, equipment, and capacity-building for organizations serving Monmouth and Ocean Counties, New Jersey. Its 2026 capacity-building awards are usually $100–$10,000, though larger requests may be considered; 2025 grants had a median of $80,108. It accepts applications for its 2026 capacity-building program, due August 14, 2026.

Assets

$40.5M

Grants

80

Total Given

$24.4M

The Becket Family Foundation

Malvern, PA

The Becket Family Foundation supports a broad range of charitable work, including animal welfare, conservation, education, housing, and workforce development, with a strong share of recent funding going to Pennsylvania and additional grants in other states. Its 2025 grants ranged from $500 to $35,000, with a median of $5,000. It accepts requests by letter describing the organization’s charitable purpose; no deadline is stated.

Assets

$9.2M

Grants

88

Total Given

$464K

More Funders in New York

Bay Street Theatre Festival Inc down — hundreds of funders to go?

Want AI to do this for you?