Church Mutual Insurance Company
Church Mutual Insurance Company Foundation, Inc., known as CM CARES®, is a private foundation based in Merrill, Wisconsin. Established by Church Mutual in 2016, it supports charitable, educational, and religious causes that advance and elevate others.
Key facts about Church Mutual Insurance Company
In short: Church Mutual Insurance Company gave $464K across 256 grants in 2025 (avg $2K), mostly in Wisconsin. 55% of 2025 grantees were new. Source: 2025 IRS Form 990-PF.
- EIN
- 47-4690250
- Latest 990 filing
- Form 990-PF, 2025
- Annual giving (2025)
- $463,887
- Grants made (2025)
- 256
- Average grant
- $1,812
- Median grant
- $500
- New grantees (estimate)
- 55% first-time grantees (129 of 235, 2025)
- Total assets
- $172,197
- Primary geography
- Wisconsin (77% of itemized 2025 grant dollars)
- How to apply
- The foundation’s 2025 filing says it does not restrict giving to preselected organizations. Full details ↓
- Deadline
- None listed in the 2025 filing.
Data from IRS Form 990-PF, 2025; updated October 2026. New grantees are estimated by matching recipient names across years (methodology). Application details from Grantable's research on the foundation's public materials; confirm on its website before applying.
Financial Overview
From 2025 IRS Form 990-PF · View filing
Total Assets
$172K
-47.0% YoY
Annual Giving
$464K
+7.6% YoY
Grant Count
256
+33.3% YoY
Avg Grant Size
$2K
-19.3% YoY
Under IRS private-foundation payout rules, Church Mutual Insurance Company reported a distributable amount of $20K for 2025 — the minimum it must pay out in qualifying distributions.
Is Church Mutual Insurance Company open to new grantees?
55%
first-time grantees, 2025
In 2025, 129 of 235 grantees (55%) were first-time recipients. First grants averaged $1K; repeat grants $3K. How we count
Medians: $500 first-time, $500 repeat.
- 31% of 2025 grantees were also funded in 2024. Method
- Giving held roughly steady from 2022 to 2025 (−4%). Method
- In 2025 it paid out well above its IRS minimum distribution (the 5% rule). Method
Estimate from itemized grant lists in IRS Form 990-PF filings (2020–2025). Recipient names are matched across years, so a renamed or misspelled grantee can look new; grants to individuals are left out. Methodology.
Mission & Focus Areas
CM CARES® says its purpose is to support charitable, educational, and religious causes that advance and elevate others. Its website names the United Way, Feeding America, the Salvation Army, and Meals on Wheels among the nonprofit causes it supports.
The 2025 grants included general operating support, United Way employee gift matching, youth support, and sponsorships. Grantees’ own descriptions illustrate the range of organizations supported: Kinship MKE says it works to address hunger, isolation, and poverty; Fellowship Open says its mission is to support organizations making a meaningful difference in the lives of Milwaukee-area low-income youth; and Lincoln County Humane Society says it works to prevent cruelty and abuse to animals, birds, and wildlife.
Grantmaking
In 2025, the foundation reported 256 grants totaling $463,887. Awards ranged from $100 to $99,967, with a median grant of $500.
Among the largest reported grants were $99,967 to Merrill Area United Way for matching United Way employee gifts; $50,000 to Northcentral Technical College Foundation for general operating support; $35,000 to Cristo Rey Jesuit High School Milwaukee for general operating support; and $20,000 to Boys & Girls Club of the Wausau Area for Merrill Technology Center sponsorship. Other $10,000 grants included support for Bethesda Mission of Harrisburg, Community Food Pantry of Merrill, Fellowship Open, Kinship MKE, River Food Pantry, and The Center for Black Excellence and Culture.
Review Cycle
None listed in the 2025 filing.
How to Apply
The foundation’s 2025 filing says it does not restrict giving to preselected organizations. It lists Dwayne Gantz as the application contact and says applicants should submit a completed application, a brief organizational history and description of the previous year’s accomplishments, the purpose of the funding request, names and brief descriptions of project partners’ roles, project and organizational budgets, and the organization’s IRS determination letter. The foundation’s website provides an application for CM CARES® donations or event sponsorships and says it can only donate to or sponsor verifiable 501(c)(3) nonprofit organizations. The filing lists no restrictions on awards.
Ready to take the next step with Church Mutual Insurance Company?
Geographic Focus
Where this funder awards grants
The 2025 filing reports that 77% of grant dollars went to Wisconsin recipients, 5% to Pennsylvania, 2% each to Florida and Indiana, and 1% to Ohio. The listed grants also include recipients in other states.
Grant Distribution by State
Share of 2025 grant dollars across all 256 itemized grants.
States
Cities
Giving Over Time
Total grant dollars and number of grants per year
From 2020 to 2025, annual grant giving ranged from $431K (2024) to $1.0M (2020). In 2025 it made 256 grants totaling $464K.
Grant Insights
How this funder distributes its grants
Top Recipients
Top 10 recipients in 2025
The largest 2025 recipient was Merrill Area United Way ($100K). Together the top 10 received $274K.
Grant Size Distribution
1,002 grants across all recorded years
The most common grant size was under $50K: 985 grants of 1,002 (98%).
Giving History
Grant recipients and amounts by year
| Recipient | Purpose | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Merrill Area United Way Merrill, WI | Matching United Way Employee Gift | $99,967 |
| Northcentral Technical College Foundation Inc Wausau, WI | General Operating Support | $50,000 |
| Cristo Rey Jesuit High School Milwaukee Milwaukee, WI | General Operating Support | $35,000 |
| Boys & Girls Club of the Wausau Area Wausau, WI | Merrill Technology Center Sponsorship | $20,000 |
| United Way of Dane County Madison, WI | Matching United Way Employee Gift | $12,812 |
| United Way of Greater Milwaukee & Waukesha County Inc Milwaukee, WI | Matching United Way Employee Gift | $10,096 |
| Bethesda Mission of Harrisburg Mechanicsburg, PA | General Operating Support | $10,000 |
| Community Food Pantry of Merrill Inc Merrill, WI | General Operating Support | $10,000 |
| Fellowship Open Inc Milwaukee, WI | Youth Support Group | $10,000 |
| Kinship MKE Milwaukee, WI | General Operating Support | $10,000 |
Financial History
Multi-year comparison from IRS filings
| Filing year | Assets | Revenue | Expenses | Grants |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $172,197 | $319,680 | $472,191 | $463,887 |
| 2024 | $324,708 | $268,936 | $441,787 | $431,206 |
| 2023 | $497,559 | $277,815 | $683,872 | $643,475 |
| Metric | 2025 | 2024 | 2023 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Assets | $172,197 | $324,708 | $497,559 |
| Revenue | $319,680 | $268,936 | $277,815 |
| Expenses | $472,191 | $441,787 | $683,872 |
| Qualifying Distributions | $472,516 | $442,012 | $686,972 |
| Net Investment Income | $14,680 | $18,936 | $27,815 |
| Distributable Amount | $19,554 | $22,173 | $38,434 |
Data update history
When this profile's IRS filing data changed on Grantable
- Added Form 990-PF for fiscal year 2025 (received by the IRS August 27, 2026)
- IRS filings on file for fiscal years 2020–2024
Leadership & Key People
Leadership team and compensation from IRS filings
The 2025 filing lists Alan S. Ogilvie as president and director; Pamela J. Rushing as executive vice president and director; Dwayne A. Gantz as treasurer and director; and David J. Endres as secretary and director. Other directors listed are Stephanie I. Lynn, Kevin D. Root, Janet L. Selnes, Pamela W. Stampen, Andrew J. Bloechl, and Carolyn Schamberger.
Church Mutual Insurance Company is led by Alan S. Ogilvie, President & Director since 2025 (on filings since 2021); none of the 10 officers listed in 2025 report compensation.
Officers on the 2025 filing
Alan S. Ogilvie
President & Director
Director → President, 2023
President → President & Director, 2025
On filings since 2021
0.1 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Kevin D. Root
Director
On filings since 2020
0.1 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Dwayne A. Gantz
Treasurer & Director
Treasurer → Treasurer & Director, 2025
On filings since 2021
0.3 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Pamela W. Stampen
Director
Senior Vice President → Director, 2024
On filings since 2021
0.1 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Andrew J. Bloechl
Director
On filings since 2023
0.3 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Pamela J. Rushing
Executive Vice President & Director
Director → Executive Vice President, 2024
Executive Vice President → Executive Vice President & Director, 2025
On filings since 2023
0.1 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Janet L. Selnes
Director
On filings since 2024
0.1 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Stephanie I. Lynn
Director
On filings since 2024
0.1 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Carolyn Schamberger
Director
New on the 2025 filing
0.1 hrs/week
No compensation reported
David J. Endres
Secretary & Director
New on the 2025 filing
0.3 hrs/week
No compensation reported
Former officers (15)
- Former: Elizabeth L. Hans (2020–2024) — Foundation Administrator
- Former: Michael M. Smith (2020–2024) — Secretary · Filing note: Began 11/2023
- Former: Heather A. Renzelmann (2023–2024) — Foundation Administrator
- Former: Cynthia M. Brandt (2020–2023) — Secretary · Filing note: Ended 11/2023
- Former: Laurie J. Thiel (2020–2023) — Director · Filing note: Ended 11/2023
- Former: Richard V. Poirier (2020–2023) — Director
- Former: Robert M. Buckley (2020–2023) — Director · Filing note: Ended 10/2023
- Former: Scott W. Steele (2020–2023) — Director · Filing note: Ended 10/2023
- Former: Alexandra Oles (2021–2023) — Director · Filing note: Ended 423
- Former: Neal W. Smith (2022–2023) — Director · Filing note: Ended 11/2023
- Former: John R. Tribble (2023) — Director
- Former: Laura E. Huggins (2023) — Director
- Former: Jeffrey D. Steffen (2020–2022) — Director · Filing note: Ended 11/2022
- Former: Angela K. Bailey (2020) — Vice President
- Former: Linda L. Voelz (2020) — Director
Data from IRS Form 990 filings, 2020–2025. "On filings since" is the earliest filing we hold that lists the person; hours are average hours per week as reported.
Contact
Application contact: Dwayne Gantz
Mailing address: 3000 Schuster Lane, Merrill, WI 54452
Phone: (715) 536-5577
Website: https://churchmutual.com
Frequently asked questions about Church Mutual Insurance Company
How much does Church Mutual Insurance Company give each year?
Church Mutual Insurance Company gave $464K across 256 grants in 2025, according to its 2025 IRS Form 990-PF. In 2024 it gave $431K across 192 grants.
What is Church Mutual Insurance Company's typical grant size?
Church Mutual Insurance Company's median grant in 2025 was $500, and its average grant was $1,812, across 256 grants on its 2025 IRS Form 990-PF. Organizations receiving their first grant from Church Mutual Insurance Company that year got $1K on average.
Where does Church Mutual Insurance Company give grants?
Church Mutual Insurance Company gives mostly in Wisconsin: 77% of the grant dollars itemized on its 2025 IRS Form 990-PF went to recipients there. The next largest state was Pennsylvania (5%). The most frequent recipient cities were Milwaukee, WI (23 grants), Wausau, WI (15 grants), Merrill, WI (13 grants) and Madison, WI (10 grants).
Does Church Mutual Insurance Company give general operating support?
Yes: 69% of Church Mutual Insurance Company's 2025 grants with a stated purpose (177 of 256) were for general or operating support, per its 2025 IRS Form 990-PF. Recurring purposes include "Annual Employee Charitable Gift" (14 grants) and "Matching United Way Employee Gift" (4 grants).
Who are Church Mutual Insurance Company's largest grantees?
Church Mutual Insurance Company's largest 2025 grantees include Merrill Area United Way ($99,967), Northcentral Technical College Foundation Inc ($50,000) and Cristo Rey Jesuit High School Milwaukee ($35,000), according to its 2025 IRS Form 990-PF. Together they received 40% of its itemized 2025 grant dollars.
How large is Church Mutual Insurance Company?
Church Mutual Insurance Company reported $172K in total assets on its 2025 IRS Form 990-PF. It paid out $473K in qualifying distributions that year, against a required minimum of $20K (roughly 5% of its investment assets).
What does Church Mutual Insurance Company fund?
CM CARES® says its purpose is to support charitable, educational, and religious causes that advance and elevate others. Its website names the United Way, Feeding America, the Salvation Army, and Meals on Wheels among the nonprofit causes it supports. See mission & focus areas ↑
How do I apply for a grant from Church Mutual Insurance Company?
The foundation’s 2025 filing says it does not restrict giving to preselected organizations. Eligibility and process details are in the grantmaking section of this profile. See how to apply ↑
What is Church Mutual Insurance Company's EIN?
Church Mutual Insurance Company's EIN (Employer Identification Number) is 47-4690250. IRS Form 990 filing data is available on this page for 2020–2025.
Data last updated October 2026. Sourced from IRS Form 990-PF filings. Research dossier generated September 2026.
Here's the math on researching Church Mutual Insurance Company by hand.
Explore Open Grants
Browse active grant opportunities in Church Mutual Insurance Company's focus areas in our free grants database
Similar Funders
Similar funders in Wisconsin
Thrivent Charitable Impact & Investing
Appleton, WI
Thrivent Charitable Impact & Investing distributes donor-directed and program donations to a broad range of causes and organizations in local, national, and global communities. Its 2024 grants had a median of $11,520 and ranged from $5,006 to $5 million. The profile does not state whether it accepts unsolicited requests.
Assets
$939.7M
Grants
2,565
Total Given
$84.6M
Alliant Energy Foundation Inc
Madison, WI
Assets
$28.5M
Grants
929
Total Given
$2.4M
Greater Milwaukee Foundation Inc
Milwaukee, WI
The Greater Milwaukee Foundation funds nonprofit programs, projects, general operations and capital needs, with priorities including early childhood education, housing, basic needs, health, arts and culture, and scientific research. Its competitive grants primarily serve Milwaukee, Ozaukee, Washington and Waukesha counties; in 2024, the median grant was about $27,800, though awards varied widely. It runs competitive grant cycles, but whether it accepts unsolicited requests is not stated.
Assets
$1.1B
Grants
838
Total Given
$66.8M
Give Back Foundation
Madison, WI
Give Back Foundation distributes donor-designated contributions through workplace giving and other giving platforms to selected 501(c)(3) charities, rather than setting its own cause areas. In 2025, grants had a median of $9,066, with recipient organizations concentrated in Virginia, California, and Washington, D.C.; it does not accept unsolicited requests or work directly with charities.
Assets
$31.3M
Grants
639
Total Given
$40.1M
United Way of Greater Milwaukee & Waukesha County Inc
Milwaukee, WI
United Way of Greater Milwaukee & Waukesha County funds local human services and community programs focused on housing stability, digital access, employment, teen mental wellness, and community resilience. Its 2025 grants ranged from $5,000 to about $2 million, with a median of about $34,000, and most funding went to Wisconsin, especially its four-county region. It requires a Letter of Intent before a full application; the listed 2026–27 Letter of Intent deadline has passed.
Assets
$50.8M
Grants
639
Total Given
$42.7M
Green Bay Packers Foundation
Green Bay, WI
The Green Bay Packers Foundation funds Wisconsin charities working in areas such as families, athletics, children’s safety and education, animal welfare, and other focus areas that vary by year. Its 2026 announcement describes typical awards of $3,000–$8,000, though some grants are larger; it accepts online applications during its stated cycle, February 2–April 1, 2026.
Assets
$57.2M
Grants
530
Total Given
$3.6M
Community Foundation for the Fox Valley Region Inc
Appleton, WI
The Community Foundation for the Fox Valley Region funds arts and culture, education, health, human services, community improvement, the environment, and other community needs, primarily in four Wisconsin counties and the Neenah-Menasha area. Its 2024 grants had a median of $24,900, though awards varied widely; some donor-initiated funds accept grant requests, and the Community Vision Fund typically uses an application process.
Assets
$536.6M
Grants
448
Total Given
$32.4M
Ab Nicholas Scholarship Foundation
Mequon, WI
The AB Nicholas Scholarship Foundation funds renewable, need-based college scholarships for Wisconsin high school seniors who played on or managed their school basketball team and plan to attend a University of Wisconsin System institution. Awards are typically $10,000 per year, renewable for up to four years; applications are submitted online during the stated February 1–April 30 application period.
Assets
$56.9M
Grants
445
Total Given
$3.5M
Mufg Union Bank Foundation Ag
Milwaukee, WI
The foundation’s 2022 grants supported work in economic opportunity, entrepreneurship, affordable housing, conservation, small-business procurement, and education, with examples in Georgia and California. It gave 441 grants totaling $8,518,500 in 2022, including awards from $45,000 to $200,000, but reported no grants in its 2023 final return. It gives only to preselected organizations and does not accept unsolicited requests.
Assets
$5.8M
Grants
441
Total Given
$8.5M
Herb Kohl Educational Foundation Inc
Milwaukee, WI
The foundation funds educational excellence in Wisconsin, including student scholarships and awards for teachers, principals, schools, and classrooms; its 2025 grants ranged from $290 to $15,000, with a median of $6,000. It directs applicants to its program applications for application details; whether it accepts unsolicited requests is not stated.
Assets
$14K
Grants
425
Total Given
$2.1M
Kelben Foundation Inc
Milwaukee, WI
Kelben Foundation supports social services, scholarships and college access, health care, and other community causes, with 98% of its 2024 grant dollars going to Wisconsin. Its 417 grants ranged from $411 to $4,005,983, with a median of $1,500; the application information provided is for a Milwaukee student scholarship, and whether it accepts unsolicited requests for other grants is not stated.
Assets
$62.7M
Grants
417
Total Given
$4.9M
More Funders in Wisconsin
Church Mutual Insurance Company down — hundreds of funders to go?