Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc
Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc is a private, nonprofit foundation established in 2005 by Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company. Headquartered in Fort Wayne, Indiana, the Foundation is a 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to making contributions that encourage religious, charitable, and educational activities and operations. The Foundation operates both at the local level in northeast Indiana and on a national scale through its Kingdom Advancing Grant initiative.
Key facts about Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc
- EIN
- 20-3618117
- Latest 990 filing
- Form 990-PF, 2024
- Annual giving (2024)
- $3,806,366
- Grants made (2024)
- 132
- Average grant
- $28,836
- Median grant
- $5,000
- New grantees (estimate)
- 32% first-time grantees (42 of 131, 2024)
- Total assets
- $7,542
- Primary geography
- Indiana (93% of itemized 2024 grant dollars)
Data from IRS Form 990-PF, 2024; updated September 2026. New grantees are estimated by matching recipient names across years (methodology).
Who Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc funds
By grant dollars, the top recipient states for Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc's 132 itemized 2024 grants were Indiana (93%). The most frequent recipient cities were Fort Wayne, IN (86 grants), Auburn, IN (4 grants), Roanoke, IN (2 grants) and Leo, IN (2 grants). 32% of grants with a stated purpose were for general or operating support. Recurring purposes include "Donation" (83 grants).
Is Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc open to new grantees?
32%
first-time grantees, 2024
In 2024, 42 of 131 grantees (32%) were first-time recipients. First grants averaged $10K; repeat grants $38K. How we count
Medians: $2K first-time, $5K repeat.
- 64% of 2024 grantees were also funded in 2023. Method
- In 2023 it paid out well above its IRS minimum distribution (the 5% rule). Method
Estimate from itemized IRS Form 990-PF grant lists (2020–2024). Recipient names are matched across years, so a renamed or misspelled grantee can look new; grants to individuals are left out. Methodology.
Next steps with Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc
- How to evaluate Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc as a funder
Our grant prospecting guide: read the 990-PF, check fit, and decide whether to apply.
- Draft an LOI to Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc with AI
AI grant writing that drafts from your organization’s own materials, in your voice.
- Track this opportunity in a free grant tracker
A free Google Sheets or Excel template for deadlines, award terms, and reports due.
Financial Overview
From 2024 IRS Form 990-PF · View filing
Total Assets
$8K
-99.0% YoY
Annual Giving
$3.8M
+115.1% YoY
Grant Count
132
+4.8% YoY
Avg Grant Size
$29K
+105.3% YoY
Mission & Focus Areas
The Foundation's mission aligns with Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company's statement: "Advancing the Kingdom by serving the Church."
Primary funding focus areas include:
- Higher education
- Housing development
- Human services
- International relief
- Christianity and religious programs
- Church innovation and ministry programs
Grantmaking
The Foundation offers two primary grantmaking programs:
Review Cycle
s
Grant Types
How to Apply
**Community Donation Requests:**
Ready to take the next step with Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc?
Geographic Focus
Where this funder awards grants
The Foundation prioritizes funding in northeast Indiana, particularly Fort Wayne. However, the Foundation has expanded its reach on a national level through the Kingdom Advancing Grant initiative, which supports innovative church programs across the United States.
Recent grant recipients have included organizations in Indiana, Pennsylvania, and Texas.
Grant Distribution by State
Share of all 132 itemized 2024 grant dollars.
States
Cities
Financial History
Multi-year comparison from IRS filings
Most Recent Data (2024):
- Total Revenue: $3,248,756
- Total Expenses: $3,981,218
- Total Assets: $7,542
Prior Year Data (2023):
- Total Assets: $740,004
- Total Giving: $1,769,925
- Number of Grants Made: 126
| Metric | 2024 | 2023 | 2020 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Assets | $7,542 | $740,004 | $542,351 |
| Revenue | $3,248,756 | $2,314,937 | $1,448,831 |
| Expenses | $3,981,218 | $1,960,366 | $1,304,022 |
| Qualifying Distributions | $3,806,366 | $1,769,925 | — |
| Net Investment Income | $2,923,053 | $2,083,406 | $1,176,974 |
| Distributable Amount | — | $2,856 | — |
Data update history
When this profile's IRS filing data changed on Grantable
- IRS filings on file for fiscal years 2020–2024
Giving Over Time
Total grant dollars and number of grants per year
Grant Insights
How this funder distributes its grants
Top Recipients
Top 10 recipients in 2024
Grant Size Distribution
353 grants across all recorded years
Giving History
Grant recipients and amounts by year
Among its reported 2024 grants, the largest recipients include Full Strength Ministries ($2,494,000), International Generosity Foundation ($112,447), Habitat for Humanity ($100,000).
| Recipient | Purpose | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Full Strength Ministries Fort Wayne, IN | General Operations | $2,494,000 |
| International Generosity Foundation Clearwater, FL | Donation | $112,447 |
| Habitat for Humanity Fort Wayne, IN | Donation | $100,000 |
| Bridge of Grace Fort Wayne, IN | General Expenses | $80,000 |
| Youth for Christ Fort Wayne, IN | General Expenses | $75,000 |
| Fort Wayne Rescue Mission Ministrie Fort Wayne, IN | Donation | $60,000 |
| Smith Academy for Excellence Fort Wayne, IN | Donation | $50,000 |
| Remedy Live FM Fort Wayne, IN | General Expenses | $46,015 |
| Associated Churches of Fort Wayne Fort Wayne, IN | General Expenses | $45,000 |
| Redemption House Fort Wayne, IN | General Expenses | $40,000 |
Leadership & Key People
Leadership team and compensation from IRS filings
Key leadership includes:
- Mark A. Robison – President
- Matthew G. Hirschy – Treasurer
- Jessica M. Inniger – Vice President
- Christopher R. Harvey – Vice President
- Mitzi L. Thomas – Vice President
- Steve W. Case – Vice President
- Erin E. Meyer – Secretary
- Kathy Bruce – Vice President
Compensation Overview
No officer or director reported compensation in the available filings.
From 2024 IRS filing
| Name | Title | Hours | Compensation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mark A Robison | President | — | — |
| Matthew G Hirschy | Treasurer | — | — |
| Jessica M Inniger | Vice President | — | — |
| Christopher R Harvey | Vice President | — | — |
| Mitzi L Thomas | Vice President | — | — |
| Steve W Case | Vice President | — | — |
| Erin E Meyer | Secretary | — | — |
| Kathy Bruce | Vice President | — | — |
Recent News & Activity
Recent developments and announcements
The Foundation has actively promoted its Kingdom Advancing Grant program in recent years:
Applications Open for 2026 Kingdom Advancing Grant: $150,000 Available to**2024:** Awarded $150,000 in Kingdom Advancing Grants to nine churches
Applications Open for 2026 Kingdom Advancing Grant: $150,000 Available to**2022:** Inaugural recipients of Kingdom Advancing Grants received a total of $150,000 across four church programs
Applications Open for 2026 Kingdom Advancing Grant: $150,000 Available to**2026:** Applications are open for the Kingdom Advancing Grant with $150,000 available to fuel church innovation
Applications Open for 2026 Kingdom Advancing Grant: $150,000 Available toRecent grant recipients have included organizations such as International Generosity Foundation Trust ($112,447), Habitat for Humanity of Greater Fort Wayne ($100,000), and Youth for Christ - YFC of Northern Indiana ($75,000).
Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Awards $150,000 in Kingdom Advancing GrantsSubject Areas
Focus areas based on grantmaking activity
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc fund?
The Foundation's mission aligns with Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company's statement: "Advancing the Kingdom by serving the Church." Primary funding focus areas include: • Higher education • Housing development • Human services • International relief • Christianity and religious programs • Church innovation and ministry programs
How do I apply for a grant from Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc?
The Foundation offers two primary grantmaking programs: **Community Donation Requests:** Funds directed to organizations in northeast Indiana and beyond, with priority given to Christian nonprofits and ministries serving northeast Indiana. Charitable nonprofits serving the region may also be considered. **Kingdom Advancing Grants:** Designed to support Christian church programs that are transforming local communities through service and ministry. The goal is to support sustainable initiatives t…
Where does Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc make grants?
The Foundation prioritizes funding in northeast Indiana, particularly Fort Wayne. However, the Foundation has expanded its reach on a national level through the Kingdom Advancing Grant initiative, which supports innovative church programs across the United States. Recent grant recipients have included organizations in Indiana, Pennsylvania, and Texas.
What size grants does Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc award?
In 2024, Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc awarded 132 grants totaling $3.8M — an average of about $29K per grant, based on its IRS Form 990 filings.
What is Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc's EIN?
Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc's EIN (Employer Identification Number) is 20-3618117. IRS Form 990 filing data is available on this page for 2020–2024.
Explore Open Grants
Browse active grant opportunities in Brotherhood Mutual Foundation Inc's focus areas in our free grants database
Similar Funders
Funders that support many of the same organizations
Community Foundation of Greater
Fort Wayne, IN
Assets
$245.4M
Grants
259
Total Given
$9.8M
Lincoln Financial Foundation Inc
Radnor, PA
Assets
—
Grants
3,159
Total Given
$8.8M
The James Foundation Inc
Auburn, IN
Assets
—
Grants
71
Total Given
$8.9M
Mary Cross Tippmann Foundation
Fort Wayne, IN
Assets
$187.7M
Grants
95
Total Given
$8.2M
Surack Family Foundation Inc
Fort Wayne, IN
Assets
—
Grants
114
Total Given
$7.4M
Lilly Endowment Inc
Indianapolis, IN
Assets
$79.9B
Grants
1,808
Total Given
$2.3B
Central Indiana Community Foundation Inc
Indianapolis, IN
Assets
$583.5M
Grants
525
Total Given
$31.1M
University of Notre Dame du Lac
Notre Dame, IN
Assets
$29.6B
Grants
462
Total Given
$84.8M
United Way of Central Indiana Inc
Indianapolis, IN
Assets
$255.2M
Grants
370
Total Given
$29.9M
Lumina Foundation for Education Inc
Indianapolis, IN
Assets
$1.5B
Grants
357
Total Given
$30.0M
Round Room Gives Inc
Fishers, IN
Assets
$1.4M
Grants
357
Total Given
$1.8M
Jpmorgan Chase Foundation
New York, NY
Assets
$1.2B
Grants
10,334
Total Given
$202.5M
More Funders in Indiana
Data last updated September 2026. Sourced from IRS Form 990-PF filings. Research dossier generated April 2026.